Cornelly

Waited about an hour for a table. Service and waiter was very good: friendly, good conversation, well dressed, attentive. Came for the pizza but partner and I thought it was overrated. Maybe we were expecting too much. But we both thought it was pretty standard, would not come back for the pizza. The spaghettini though! That was very good. Well flavored, good texture, simple and really tasted different. Would come back for the pasta.

TLDR: excellent food, but long wait and the hostess won’t let you move to a table if you’re at the bar. The red funghi pizza is by far the best mushroom pizza I have ever had. We also ordered the fussilli which was quite nice too. Our waitress was very helpful throughout. My only beef is with the hostess - we were seated at the bar and 10 minutes in, a few tables opened up. We asked to be moved to those tables but were told that because of the waitlist, she needed them. I assumed this meant that there was probably a party of 4 on the list that couldn’t possibly be seated at the bar, which makes sense. But another 10 minutes in, both the tables were given to two different parties of 2. So ultimately I can’t for the life of me figure out why we couldn’t have been moved to a table. After having been on the waitlist for almost an hour, I do feel like moving us to a table once it opened up was the least they could have done. Really annoyed at this experience, but like I said, the food is incredible!

I'm from Chicago and was more than a little skeptical that I would find good pizza in Seattle. But I checked out a few best list and Cornelly was mentioned on several so with hopeful spirits we checked it out. And I'm so glad we did. I think this is the second best pizza place I've been to (previously occupied by Coalfire in Chicago). If you're looking for delicious thin crust pizza then you need to check out Cornelly. I especially recommend the hornet honey pizza. Besides the good food, the ambiance was great as well. We sat at the bar and enjoyed watching the kitchen staff working away in the back. Cannot wait to come back on my next trip.

Wow. Just wow. Amazing meal from start to finish. The winner for me was the Spring Asparagus with a Carrot Mole. It will be a bummer for those that don’t get to try it, as I’m fairly certain their veggie choices are seasonal, but honestly the best asparagus I’ve ever had and honestly one of the best vegetable dishes I e ever eaten. The pizza was amazing and fired perfectly. The rigatoni has a bolognese with mint and it was a game changer. Not sure if the house made huckleberry ice cream is a fixture, but if it’s on the menu you absolutely need to order it.

loved the pizza here. but you have to come early or it will take awhile to sit down. i was disappointed with the rigatoni…as it was too salty for my taste even though others seem to love it. we ordered three pizzas but received them oddly at different times. the first was delivered and then the other two 35 min later. we were trying to save two slices for someone else but almost ate the whole first pizza as we had to wait soo long for the 2nd and 3rd. i love there pepperoni with joni and hot spice!! but you have to try the fennel sausage one as well!! yummy!! wish we could go again!!

I brought my partner here for his birthday. We were completely blown away. The food was excellent, the service was friendly with just the right amount of attentive and the atmosphere was perfect. It’s elevated causal, felt so comfortable but like we were giving ourselves a real treat. We’re vegetarian but we ordered the hornet honey without the pepperoni even though they had a vegan pizza on the menu. Everything was amazing. The Brussels sprouts, the bread, the drinks, the pizza. Don’t sleep on the ice cream, it was really delicious! There was a wait but it went quick and we had a chance to pop next door to Sol Liquor for a pre dinner drink, which was great. This just may be our new favorite spot in Seattle’s, we couldn’t recommend more. We’re very excited to come back. We absolutely loved it.

Terrible wait service. The waiter clearly does not like women and fawns all over men. Maybe he thinks he will get a better tip from men. The waiter took our order. He came back with a pizza. That was it. The waiter never asked if we wanted chili flakes. He never returned to ask if our pizza was any good. What was extremely annoying was that the waiter kept going over to 3 guys at the next table and asking if they wanted anything more. The waiter was not even the 3 guys server. There was another waiter for the 3 guys. After 1 hour I had to flag the waiter to come over and give us a bill. But, even then, he went to the 3 guys at the next table to ask if they needed anything before coming to our table. There was no reason for the waiter to be such a jerk to our table. He could have been nice to our table and tried to hit on the 3 guys at the next table at the same time! I would never return to Cornelly that allows that kind of biased behavior from waiters.

Def one of the cutest local spots, the place’s atmosphere is amazing & the staff is super nice, it’s kinda slow & the pizza was not up to my expectations tbh, but the food definitely feels quality (got the fennel sausage for takeout & forgot to take pic to the whole pizza). Might go there if I actually dine in, otherwise I’ll order from serious pie lol, also my pizza took 1h30 to be ready, and I still had to wait ~10 min when I picked it up.